Your best biller knocks on your door at 4:45 on a Thursday. Two weeks’ notice.
You say congratulations, and you mean it. Meanwhile, your brain is already running a list. Who else knows which payer only accepts corrected claims through its portal? Who has the clearinghouse password? Who’s tracking the appeals due on the 20th?
If the answer to all of those is the person standing in your doorway, keep reading.
What Walks Out the Door
A good biller carries a lot in their head. Most of it never made it into a manual.
They know one payer will reject a certain code on first submission, so they fix it before it goes out. They keep a spreadsheet of every open appeal on their desktop. Nobody asked them to build it. They just did, and now it leaves with them.
For the first few weeks, things can look fine. Claims submitted before the handoff are still paying. Then the slowdown starts. Submissions lag. Denials sit in the queue because the remaining team is busy keeping new claims moving. Your 60-day bucket gets heavier, then your 90-day bucket. Some of that money comes back with extra work. Some of it passes the timely filing limit and is gone for good.
The Cost of Starting Over
AAPC estimates that replacing a revenue cycle employee can cost 200% of their annual pay.
And that assumes you find someone. Experienced billers have lots options right now, and many of them want to work remotely. If you can only hire people who can drive to your office, the pool shrinks fast. Even a strong hire could need months to learn your EHR and your payers before they’re working at full speed. Then you have to keep them.
None of this means your team failed or your hiring process is broken. The market is hard. Here’s how to plan for it anyway.
Before Anyone Leaves
Organizations that get through a resignation without a revenue dip usually did the unglamorous work months earlier.
Write it down. Payer rules and appeal steps belong somewhere shared. A binder on one person’s desk doesn’t count.
Give every job a backup. For example, if only one person has ever posted payments, you have a single point of failure. Pick a second person and have them do it once a month so the skill stays fresh.
Own your logins. Portal and clearinghouse credentials belong to the organization, not to an employee. Keep a secure central list and update it whenever someone’s access changes.
Watch the numbers monthly. Days in AR and denial rate can show you something is slipping weeks before your bank balance does.
When the Notice Comes First
Maybe none of that is in place yet. That’s okay! Two weeks is enough time to save a lot.
Use the notice period to get knowledge out of their head and onto paper. Block an hour a day. Have them walk you through open appeals and any payer quirks, and record those sessions on Zoom or Teams so you can rewatch them later. Make sure you move every login to someone else before their last day.
Then decide what comes first. Clean claims go out on time, because that’s next month’s cash. Denials and appeals close to their filing deadlines come next. Older AR can wait a few weeks, but put a date on the calendar to get back to it.
If you can’t fill the seat within a month, get outside help early. This outside help can take a few different forms.
The quickest fix is usually a person. A temp agency or contract biller can cover the basics while you recruit. So can a former employee who knows your systems and would like a few hours of side work. Expect a learning curve, though. A temp may know billing without knowing your payers, and you’ll still be the one assigning and checking the work.
The other route is an outsourced billing team, and for many organizations it’s the better fit. An experienced revenue cycle company brings billers who already know payer rules, and they work inside the EHR you already use. You don’t train them. You don’t replace them if someone leaves. You also don’t have to hand over everything! Plenty of organizations start with one function, like denials or AR follow-up, and keep the rest in-house until they’ve rebuilt their team.
Whichever route you pick, make the call by week four. Catching up on 60-day AR is usually far easier than chasing 120-day AR.
A Note for FQHCs
Health centers have it harder when it comes to losing key billing staff. PPS encounter rules and wraparound reconciliation are specialized work, and plenty of billers with ten years of experience have never touched either one. Especially if you’re in a rural area, finding someone local who has these skills can take months.
The stakes are different, for health centers too. A wraparound submission that never happens is money your community programs were counting on. For a health center, a continuity plan protects the mission as much as the budget.
Getting Through the Transition
Every organization deals with turnover eventually. You can’t prevent it, but you can decide how much it costs you.
If you need more than a short-term fix, Practice Management provides full revenue cycle management through a fully remote, U.S.-based team that logs into the systems you already use. You get experienced revenue cycle managers, including people who have spent years on FQHC billing, without hiring locally or spending months on training. Every client has a dedicated RCM and monthly calls with our team. We work like your own billing department and come locked and loaded with an entire team behind us.
Only need help with one piece? Maybe someone to work denials while you hire, or to take over AR follow-up for a few months. We can do that, too. If those services sound like something you’re interested in learning more about, we’d love to connect and figure out exactly what fits your needs best.